Should I Pay Off the Mortgage Early or Invest?

Saving for retirement and paying off the mortgage are two of the biggest money goals most people will ever tackle. And deciding which one to tackle first can feel like a financial tug-of-war.

On one side, you have the freedom and peace that comes with a paid-for house. But on the other hand, the magic of compound interest is pulling you toward investing. So which one should take priority in your financial journey?

The answer is . . . drumroll, please . . . both!

Both investing and paying off the mortgage play a huge role in setting yourself up for retirement. And guess what? It’s 100% possible to pay off your mortgage early while also investing. If you follow the Baby Steps, you know we recommend investing 15% of your income for retirement in Baby Step 4 and then putting any extra money you can toward the mortgage simultaneously (that’s Baby Step 6).

So, let’s take a look at why investing and paying off the mortgage early are key to your retirement’s financial outlook and how you can reach those goals!

Paying Off the Mortgage and Investing: Why Both Are Important

We want to be clear: Before you can retire, you’re going to want both a solid nest egg and a paid-for house. Together, these two financial goals will set you up for a more secure, financially stable retirement.  

Let’s talk about why both are an important part of your financial journey and plans for the future.

Saving for Retirement

Newsflash: You’re going to retire someday. That’s a fact! What your retirement looks like, on the other hand, is mostly up to you. Here are some reasons you need to start saving for retirement sooner rather than later.     

You need a nest egg for retirement.

Listen, folks—your living expenses and bills won’t magically disappear the day you retire. You’re still going to need money in the bank to live on, and that’s why it’s important to start investing to build a nest egg. It’ll be a lot easier to enjoy the fruits of your labor and live comfortably in retirement if you aren’t constantly worrying about money.

The earlier you start, the more time you give compound interest to grow your money.

Compound interest is the secret sauce for building wealth. It’s your best friend as you continue to save and invest for the future, helping your money grow faster and faster.

But here’s the deal: Compound interest takes time to work. A lot of time! Investing is a marathon, not a sprint. That’s why we recommend putting 15% of your income toward retirement first before you start throwing extra money toward your mortgage.

Want to retire early? Investing is key.

Some people may tell you retiring early is impossible, especially in this economy. But it isn’t just a dream reserved for a lucky few—it’s a tangible goal you can work toward. Retirement isn’t an age, it’s a financial number. And although it takes a lot of hard work and sacrifice to reach that number, it all starts with the two goals we’ve been discussing: investing and paying off the mortgage.  

This is a good place to pause for a friendly reminder: Don’t skip ahead in the Baby Steps (which we’ll go over in detail below) and start investing before you’re ready. Paying off debt first and staying out of debt will free up more of your income to save, so stick with the plan and you could be well on your way to retiring early or semi-retiring to start the small business you’ve been dreaming of.

Most millionaires invest in their company’s 401(k).

According to Ramsey’s National Study of Millionaires, 8 out of 10 millionaires invested in their company’s 401(k). And 3 out of 4 said regular, consistent investing was the key to their success.

How much will you need for retirement? Find out with this free tool!

And the top five careers of millionaires? Engineers, accountants, teachers, managers and attorneys. In fact, only 15% of millionaires held senior leadership roles (like CEO, CFO or COO). Ninety-three percent said they got their wealth because they worked hard and consistently invested in their retirement account, not because they had big salaries.

Ramsey Solutions is a paid, non-client promoter of participating pros. 

Paying the Mortgage Off Early

When you make that final mortgage payment on your home and you own it outright, the grass just feels different under your feet. We want you to experience that feeling someday! Here are a couple reasons why having a paid-for home is an important part of your financial journey.  

A paid-for house provides stability.

There are a lot of uncontrollables when it comes to retirement. Who knows what the price of gas and groceries will be when you get ready to retire (not to mention what interest rates will be like)?

But having a paid-for house is like having your own personal anchor made of brick and mortar. It’ll help keep your finances steady, no matter how stormy the stock market or economy might be during your retirement. When you pay off your mortgage early, you won’t have to spend your retirement worrying about fluctuating interest rates or what the housing market is doing.

 

No more mortgage payments means more margin in your budget.

Mortgage payments can suck your retirement savings dry every month. They can keep you from spending money on the very things that made you want to retire in the first place, like spending more time with grandkids, visiting your bucket list national parks, or starting your own llama farm (because why not?).

More margin in your budget means more flexibility and freedom, which is what retirement is all about!

Should You Pay Off the Mortgage Before or After Investing for Retirement?

Investing for retirement comes first—it’s the priority. We know you’d love to get out from under the weight of a mortgage. Being completely debt-free feels so liberating! You’ll get there, we promise. 

But by investing first, you’re giving time and compound interest the opportunity to work. (Just play around with our Investment Calculator to see for yourself.) Not only that, but you’ll also earn a lot more in interest in an investment than you’d be saving if you paid off your house first.

Let’s crunch the numbers, starting with our Mortgage Payoff Calculator.

Pretend you have a $200,000, 15-year fixed-rate mortgage at an interest rate of 6.5%. You’d be making monthly mortgage payments of about $1,740. In 15 years, you’d pay around $113,600 in interest. But if you paid $300 extra per month, you’d save about $26,500 in interest and pay it off about three years sooner. Not bad.

But what if you put that $300 into a retirement fund instead? For this math, we used our Investment Calculator. Here’s what we learned: After 15 years, you’d have over $136,000, assuming an 11% annual rate of return. Now here’s where it gets fun. If you left that money in the investment account for another 10 years, you’d have almost $408,000. Compound interest does its best if you give it plenty of time to work.

Will you work hard to pay off your house early? Absolutely. But remember, as you hit the prime of your career, you’ll be making a lot more. After you invest your 15% every month, you should have money left over to put toward extra mortgage payments.

If all you have for retirement right now is a paid-for home—or you’re pushing hard toward that goal—then you’re ahead of the crowd by far. You already have the drive and ambition to make wise money choices. But you still have some work to do.

Start by partnering with an investing professional to create a workable plan. They’ll show you how a paid-for home fits into your overall financial goals. Plus, they’ll give you valuable perspective on how much money you’ll need to enjoy your golden years.

How You Can Pay Off the Mortgage Early and Invest at the Same Time

According to a recent Ramsey Solutions research study, more than half of Americans aren’t saving enough for retirement. Only 1 in 10 Americans saves the recommended 15% for retirement. While cost of living is the number one reason non-savers aren’t stashing away cash for retirement, lack of planning is another barrier to saving.

But when folks get on a proven plan and stick with it, they can change their financial outlook and set themselves up for a great retirement with a paid-for house and more savings than they ever thought possible.

Let’s back up for a second and explain the 7 Baby Steps, the financial game plan that has helped millions of people get out of debt and build wealth. Here are the first three steps:          

• Baby Step 1: Save $1,000 for your starter emergency fund. 
• Baby Step 2: Pay off all debt (except the house) using the debt snowball.
• Baby Step 3: Save 3–6 months of expenses in a fully funded emergency fund.

When you’re working through those first three steps, you do them in order. One step at a time. But with Baby Steps 4–6, it works a bit differently. First off, here’s a quick definition of them:

• Baby Step 4: Invest 15% of your household income in retirement.
• Baby Step 5: Save for your children’s college fund.
• Baby Step 6: Pay off your home early.

You start with Baby Step 4 because investing for retirement comes first—it’s the priority. Then, if you have kids and a mortgage, put any extra cash you can toward those Baby Steps while you’re saving for retirement.

How much should you put toward paying off your mortgage early? That’s entirely up to you and how much money you (and your spouse) are willing to throw at the house. But keep in mind that making one extra mortgage payment each year could shave several years off the life of the loan and save you thousands of dollars in interest.    

Once the mortgage is paid off and the kids are through college, you can put check marks next to all three of those and move to Baby Step 7: Build wealth and give. This is the goal. Because when you don’t have any payments in the world, you’ll be able to stash away tons of cash in investments and savings. And even better than that, you’ll have the ability to be outrageously generous, which is the most fun you’ll ever have with money.

Work With a Financial Advisor

If the thought of investing for retirement while paying off the mortgage early has you feeling, well . . . overwhelmed, don't worry. You don't have to go it alone!

Working with a financial advisor or investment professional can help you tackle each step of the process without sabotaging your overall goals. An investment professional like those in our SmartVestor program can help answer any questions you may have about planning for retirement and staying on track.

 

This article provides general guidelines about investing topics. Your situation may be unique. To discuss a plan for your situation, connect with a SmartVestor Pro. Ramsey Solutions is a paid, non-client promoter of participating Pros.